Gas Steam Boiler VS Oil Steam Boiler – Boiler Guide

Taking a 10 ton/hour (≈10tph) steam boiler as an example, a comprehensive comparison is made between oil-fired steam boilers and natural gas-fired steam boilers.

1. Steam Boiler Working Principles

• Oil‑fired steam boiler
  Fuel oil is pressurized and atomized through a nozzle in the burner, creating a fine mist that mixes with combustion air and ignites in the furnace. Hot flue gases then pass through fire‑tubes (or water‑tubes) transferring heat to boiler water, generating steam.

• Gas‑fired steam boiler
  Natural gas is metered and premixed with combustion air (in a forced‑draft burner) before ignition. The resulting flame heats the boiler’s heat‑exchange surfaces, producing steam. Turndown ratios of 5:1–10:1 allow modulation of firing rate for matching load.

2. Investment Cost Analysis

Note: Riello condensing models offer up to 98 % efficiency on gas and are available with dual‑fuel options, but carry a premium over non‑condensing units.

3. Installation Cost Analysis

• FangKuai Oil Steam Boiler
  Requires on‑site fuel storage (tank, leak containment), diesel piping and filtration. Flue system may need corrosion‑resistant lining if high‑sulfur oil is used.

• FangKuai Gas Steam Boiler
  Involves tying into the municipal gas main, installing a pressure‑reducing station, and gas‑safety interlocks. No storage tank or oil filtration is needed.

Typical comparison: installation of an oil‑fired boiler can be 15–25 % more expensive than a gas boiler of the same capacity, owing to the extra civil works and environmental controls for the fuel‑oil system.

4. Operating Cost & Thermal Efficiency

Conclusion: gas steam boilers typically halve fuel costs compared to oil at these efficiency and fuel‐price levels.

5. Emission Comparison

Data sourced from fuel‐characteristics studies and burner tests.

6. Safety Factor Comparison

• Oil‑fired systems

  • Risks: fuel‑oil leaks (fire hazard), pump‑failure releases, soot buildup

  • Protections: flame detectors, leak pans, automatic shutdown on flame loss

• Gas‑fired systems

  • Risks: natural gas leaks (explosion hazard), flashback, CO poisoning

  • Protections: gas‑leak detectors, excess‑air interlocks, redundant safety shutoff valves

Both systems adhere to ASME and local codes; overall incident rates are low when properly maintained.

Get a Steam Boiler Quote List

7. Usage Scenarios & Selection Suggestions

• Remote or no‑gas‑line sites
  Choose oil‑fired boiler—diesel (or bio‑blend) storage ensures fuel availability.

• Urban or industrial parks with reliable gas supply
  Choose gas‑fired boiler for lower fuel/maintenance costs and cleaner emissions.

• High‑efficiency, low‑emission requirement
  Opt for a condensing gas boiler (Riello RTC series up to 98 % efficiency).

• Backup or dual‑fuel operation
  Consider dual‑fuel Riello burners capable of switching between oil and gas seamlessly.

8. Conclusion

For a 10 tph steam application with Riello burners:

• Capital investment is roughly on par, with gas boilers slightly favored in competitive markets.

• Installation is simpler and typically ~15 % cheaper for gas, given no oil‑tank groundwork.

• Operating costs for gas are about 50 % lower at current fuel prices and efficiencies.

• Emissions from gas are substantially cleaner (virtually zero SO₂/particulates).

• Safety profiles differ but are equivalent under proper controls.

• Recommendation: where pipeline gas is accessible, a modern condensing gas steam boiler offers the best lifecycle cost and environmental performance. In off‑grid or backup‑critical sites, oil‑fired steam boilers remain a robust choice.

We are a Class A boiler manufacturer in China, providing you with free services in boiler selection, boiler room design, etc.